DeFi contracts are not illegal but alegal: CFTC briefing


Developers often describe DeFi projects as financial Lego blocks, presenter Aaron Wright stated
Decentralised Finance (DeFi) has been one of 2020s biggest crypto trends. Powered by protocols that didn’t exist a few years ago, the total value and number of DeFi projects have risen dramatically in recent months.
To understand and respond to this explosion in DeFi, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s (CFTC) Technology Advisory Committee hosted a presentation called “The Growth and Regulatory Challenges of Decentralised Finance” by law professor Aaron Wright and attorney Gary DeWaal yesterday.
The presentation was delivered mostly in the form of a briefing on the operations of decentralised platforms which have shown greater influence in crypto trading.
Wright explained the potential of DeFi in enabling the provision of services at a lower cost for a greater number of people by the automation of processes involved. He further pointed out that software tools can contribute to an overall increase in flexibility.
“Another interesting benefit of decentralised financial projects is that they’re composable and interactable”, said Wright. “Developers often describe them as financial Lego blocks”, he added.
Wright made a few insightful observations regarding the regulatory compliance of DeFi projects by pointing out that developers typically don’t think of legal considerations first.
“These contracts are alegal. That doesn’t mean that they are illegal. It means they are designed at a technical level, not necessarily with regulatory compliance in mind”, Wright explained.
The presenters highlighted technological barriers to entry as another potential risk that can challenge the growth of DeFi despite DeFi’s ideal of being more open-access than Centralised Finance(CeFi). Further, the chronic risk to know-your-customer and anti-money laundering violation posed by little or no registration requirements for users was also discussed.
DeWaal’s briefing centred around the question of who authorities can hold liable if a DeFi platform is functioning illegally. While speculations suggest more legal action against software developers in the future, DeWaal explained that that’s a tough legal bar to clear.
“Generally, in the United States, software development is a protected activity under the first amendment”, said DeWaal. “As Aaron has eloquently shown, there’s many, many use cases for DeFi. But the First Amendment is not a universal bar”, he explained. The attorneys also noted that secondary liability can threaten a diverse population of people using or contributing to DeFi protocols.
Wright discussed possible solutions by mentioning a potential safe harbour within the virtual currencies’ subcommittee. “A safe harbour could ensure responsible development to protect consumers’ interests without limited innovation”, he concluded.
Keep updated with our round the clock and in-depth cryptocurrency news.
Unsub anytime
No SPAM ever!
After signing up, you may also receive occasional special offers from us via email. We will never sell or distribute your data to any third parties. View our privacy policy here.
Please be aware that some of the links on this site will direct you to the websites of third parties, some of whom are marketing affiliates and/or business partners of this site and/or its owners, operators and affiliates. We may receive financial compensation from these third parties. Notwithstanding any such relationship, no responsibility is accepted for the conduct of any third party nor the content or functionality of their websites or applications. A hyperlink to or positive reference to or review of a broker or exchange should not be understood to be an endorsement of that broker or exchange’s products or services.
Risk Warning: Investing in digital currencies, stocks, shares and other securities, commodities, currencies and other derivative investment products (e.g. contracts for difference (“CFDs”) is speculative and carries a high level of risk. Each investment is unique and involves unique risks.
CFDs and other derivatives are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. You should consider whether you understand how an investment works and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.
Cryptocurrencies can fluctuate widely in prices and are, therefore, not appropriate for all investors. Trading cryptocurrencies is not supervised by any EU regulatory framework. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Any trading history presented is less than 5 years old unless otherwise stated and may not suffice as a basis for investment decisions. Your capital is at risk.
When trading in stocks your capital is at risk.
Past performance is not an indication of future results. Trading history presented is less than 5 years old unless otherwise stated and may not suffice as a basis for investment decisions. Prices may go down as well as up, prices can fluctuate widely, you may be exposed to currency exchange rate fluctuations and you may lose all of or more than the amount you invest. Investing is not suitable for everyone; ensure that you have fully understood the risks and legalities involved. If you are unsure, seek independent financial, legal, tax and/or accounting advice. This website does not provide investment, financial, legal, tax or accounting advice. Some links are affiliate links. For more information please read our full risk warning and disclaimer.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Previous Post

Bitcoin miners recorded $1.4 billion in revenue last month

Next Post

Bill allowing state banks to custody digital assets proposed by Senator Flood

Related Posts